How toastie works
Fresh rolls. Simple process.
Toastie is pre-order only so every roll is baked fresh in small batches. Here’s the simple process from order to pickup.
Step 1.
Pre-order your pack
Choose your pack size (4, 6, or 12 pack) and select your flavors.
Pay in full at checkout to reserve your spot — quantities are limited.
Step 3.
Select pickup or delivery at checkout
Free Pickup: Glenview, IL
Wednesday Pickup from 6-8 PM
Saturday Pickup from 6-8 PM
Address shared after purchase
Local Delivery: Within 10 miles — $8 flat fee
Wednesday Delivery from 5-6 PM
Saturday Delivery from 5-6 PM
Step 2.
Choose your bake day
We bake on Wednesdays and Saturdays, then pickup and delivery happens the same evening.
〰
〰
〰 〰
ordering cutoff times
To keep every batch fresh and organized, ordering closes at 9:00 PM the night before baking (we do not accept same-day orders).
For Wednesday fulfillment: ordering closes Tuesday at 9:00 PM
For Saturday fulfillment: ordering closes Friday at 9:00 PM
〰
〰
〰 〰
Made-to-order policy
Because everything is made to order:
No refunds after order cutoff time
Changes are easiest before order cutoff time
If anything comes up, contact ASAP and we’ll try to reschedule
〰
〰
〰 〰
storage & reheat
Best way to enjoy
Best enjoyed same day
Store airtight
Warm briefly to bring back to fresh-baked softness